Critical Babble – Where Do Solutions Come From?

May 11, 2012

By Matt Palmer

After my last post, a commenter called my blog “critical babble”. Fair enough, I cannot argue how someone feels about my writing, in fact, I encourage dissenting opinions, and honest debate over the written and filmed content I produce. The respondent (they posted with an anonymous email) went on to say that if I had some potential answers, I would be worth listening to. While I do not pretend to have any answers, I do hope I am inspiring readers here to embrace systems thinking as we approach solutions. Systems thinking is not an answer itself, but a framework to help design rational and pragmatic solutions to the complex area of energy.

I get the point about “critical babble” in that it is easy to sit back and poke holes in  proposals like the one presented by Amory Lovins. It is also easy to sit back and be a cheerleader and not question the efficacy of a plan presented by a respected individual or institution. The best solutions come from continually questioning, probing, pushing to see where things break and where they can evolve and get better.

There is a lot of critical babble out there. News sites are filled with contrarian pundits. I don’t usually spend much time reading comments sections on news and other websites, because so many of the comments tend towards being  unconstructive, disrespectful, and polarizing. It is nice to see when there are thoughtful and considerate people making an effort to further a debate.

Where do solutions come from? Sometimes the best solutions come from experts with a complex and profound understanding of the issues and challenges. The Systems Thinkers with a great capacity for big visions and divergent thought. And, every once in a while, amazing breakthroughs come from outsiders with no knowledge, who can look at a problem and see something that none of the experts could see or understand. Solutions might also be spurred by invigorating debate where all ideas and proposed solutions are challenged, and as long as things are respectful, no idea is off-limits and there are no sacred solutions.

We can let fear of a different idea hold us back, or feel uncomfortable when someone challenges our core beliefs, but will that allow us to live to our greatest potential? I hate being controlled by fear, and honestly, creating this project, writing what I write forces me to confront those fears. It does not mean we have to throw caution to the wind, but it does mean we need to peer into the shadows more.


About Unintended Consequences Documentary Project

I'm Producing and directing a multi-platform documentary project on global energy called "Unintended Consequences".
This entry was posted in Unintended Consequences and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Critical Babble – Where Do Solutions Come From?

  1. Great post Matt. Just because someone is an “expert” in a particular field doesn’t mean he’s got it right. A friend once deeply involved in the world of politics said the most dangerous players in government today aren’t the politicians, they’re the Chicago School economists the politicians are relying on. Time and again their economic solutions have failed but the fact that they are world famous experts makes others unwilling to challenge their ideas. We don’t need more cheerleaders, we need more people prepared to “peer into the shadows”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s